A Sermon for the Third Sunday of Easter (Year C)
May 4, 2025
Text: John 21:1-19
Now, O Lord, take my lips, and speak through them. Take our minds, and think through them. Take our hearts, and set them on fire. In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit. Amen.
Have you ever felt like you turned your back on God? Have you ever had a moment when you realized how far you’ve fallen away and were unsure if God could ever forgive you?
Not just a little bit.
I’m talking about a time when you really messed up and felt like you let God down.
If so, you’re in good company.
Because I think all of us, at one time or another, have felt like that.
Maybe we promised to do something, and, for whatever reason, we didn’t do it.
Or, maybe the fire we once had for coming to church and being involved in ministry has fizzled out, and we no longer feel connected in the same way we used to.
Or, maybe the wellspring in our souls has dried up, and we no longer feel close to God and wonder if he’s even there.
If any of those sound familiar to you—know that aren’t alone.
We’ve all struggled with failure.
We’ve all fallen short of our call to walk in love as Christ taught us.
We’ve all experienced moments of doubt and uncertainty.
And, hopefully—for all of us—we’ve known what it means to be forgiven and restored.
A few years ago, after the worst of the pandemic was over, I found myself spiritually and emotionally exhausted.
I was serving at a small parish in Alabaster at the time—just outside of Birmingham.
The pressures of having to lead a church during COVID were heavy, but even harder than that was having to come back to church and pick up the pieces after it was over.
When things began to return to “normal” (if you could call it that), I realized that I wasn’t okay.
Something had changed.
I was exhausted all the time and frustrated that people weren’t come back to church, and I began to seriously question if God was still calling me to be a priest.
I was in the process of slowly burning out in my ministry.
I was still showing up to church when I needed to and leading services on Sunday mornings, but my spirit just wasn’t in it.
I felt like a failure.
I felt distant and dried up, and I finally came to realize that, if something didn’t change, I wasn’t going to make it as a priest.
In my prayers, I asked God to show me the way and to lead me where he would have me go.
As it turns out, the place where he was calling me to go was right back to where the story of my life began.
So, we moved back home to Andalusia, and we found a community at St. Mary’s that loved us and welcomed us in with open arms.
A community with a passion for service and outreach.
A community that takes very seriously our call to live and love like Jesus.
And, it was during that time when I found that fire again that I once had.
It was during that time when I realized that God wasn’t done with me yet—that God still had important work for me to do as a priest.
I want to take you back a couple of weeks to Good Friday.
If you were in church that day, you heard the story of our Lord’s Passion and death retold from John’s Gospel.
At the beginning of the story, after Jesus was arrested in the garden and taken away, Simon Peter and another disciple followed behind him.
They came to the courtyard of the high priest, which is where Jesus had been taken for questioning.
The other disciple—the one who was with Peter—was known to the high priest.
So, he was allowed to go in with Jesus while Peter had to stay outside.
The other disciple went out and spoke to the woman who was guarding the gate and convinced her to let Peter in.
The woman asked Peter, “Aren’t you one of this man’s disciples?”
Peter responded, “I am not.”
The servants and police who were standing in the courtyard had made a charcoal fire in order to stay warm.
Peter also stood with them next to the fire.
A little while later, after Jesus was questioned by the high priest, Simon Peter was still standing next to the fire in the courtyard.
The others who were there asked him, “Aren’t you one of his disciples?”
Peter denied it.
“Not me” he said.
Then, finally, one of the high priest’s servants, a relative of the man whose ear Peter had cut off in the garden, said, “Didn’t I see you in the garden with him?”
Again, Peter denied it, and at that moment, a rooster crowed.
Peter knew what he had done and immediately remembered what Jesus had said to him earlier that night.
“Before the rooster crows, you will deny me three times.”
That’s the last time we hear from Peter in John’s Gospel until after Jesus is raised from the dead.
But, Luke’s Gospel adds even more emotional weight to the story.
In Luke’s version, after Peter denies Jesus a third time, Jesus turns and looks at him, and he remembers what Jesus told him.
Luke’s version of the story also adds that Peter went out and wept bitterly.
He had failed as a disciple.
He had failed his friend and teacher.
How could Jesus ever forgive him?
Thankfully, Peter’s story doesn’t end there.
Later in John’s Gospel, in chapter 21—which is where our story picks up today—we learn that Jesus appears to his disciples one final time after his resurrection.
This time, Simon Peter—along with six others—are fishing along the Sea of Galilee.
They’ve been fishing all night long and haven’t caught a single fish.
Soon, after day break, Jesus appears on the beach, but they don’t recognize him at first.
He says to the disciples, “Good morning! Did you catch anything for breakfast?”
They tell him no.
So, he tells them to throw their net to the right side of the boat and see what happens.
They do as they’re told, and all of a sudden, there are so many fish in the net that they can’t pull it back in the boat.
At once, the beloved disciple recognizes Jesus and says to Simon Peter, “It is the Lord!”
Simon Peter wastes no time.
He puts his clothes back on, dives into the water, and swims to shore.
A little while later, the other disciples come in by boat, pulling the net full of fish behind them.
Jesus tells them to bring some of the fish they caught and join him on the beach for breakfast.
After breakfast, Peter is alone with Jesus on the beach.
It doesn’t say this in the Gospel, but in my holy imagination, he’s anxiously waiting to hear what Jesus will say.
This is the first time they’ve been alone together since the night when he turned away from Jesus.
He’s probably thinking to himself, “Will he be angry?”
“Will he be disappointed?”
Or, worst of all, “Will he be done with me?”
Jesus takes him aside and says, “Simon, son of John, do you love me more than these?”
Peter says, “Yes, Lord. You know that I love you.”
“Feed my lambs,” Jesus says.
A second time, Jesus says to Peter, “Simon, son of John, do you love me?”
And a second time, Peter responds, “Yes, Lord. You know that I love you.”
“Tend my sheep,” Jesus says.
A final time, Jesus says to Simon Peter, “Simon, son of John, do you love me?”
This time, Peter feels hurt.
Maybe it was because he desperately wanted Jesus to believe him.
Or, maybe it was because of the shame and guilt he felt from denying Jesus and abandoning him in his most desperate time of need.
He says to Jesus, “Lord, you know everything. You know that I love you.”
“Feed my sheep,” Jesus says.
Three times, Jesus asks, “Do you love me,” taking Peter right back to that night when he denied Jesus three times.
Three questions for three denials.
It’s not to scold him or make him feel worse about what he’s done.
It’s not to shame him or make him feel guilty.
It’s his way of bringing Peter back to life again.
In that moment, Jesus doesn’t just forgive Peter.
He does something far more miraculous.
He restores him.
And—even more than that—he reassures Peter that there is still a place for him.
Despite his failure, all is not lost.
This is why Jesus doesn’t just say, “I forgive you.”
He says, “Feed my sheep.”
In other words, “It’s time to get back to who you are and who you were called to be.”
Maybe, in that moment, Peter was taken even further back in his story with Jesus and reminded of the time when he and his brother, Andrew, were called to follow.
The very first time Jesus laid his eyes on Simon, he looked up and said, “You are Simon, son of John. From now on your name is Cephas.” (or Peter, which means “Rock”).
When we fall away from God, Jesus makes a way for us to come back.
When we fail God or fall short in our calling, Jesus doesn’t just forgive us. He restores us to fullness of life.
When we struggle with doubt and uncertainty—when we wonder whether or not God can still use us, despite our worst mistakes—Jesus is there to remind us of who we are and who we were called to be.
“Feed my sheep,” Jesus says.
It’s not just for Peter.
It’s for all of us.
It’s for all of us who have answered God’s call to follow and who need to be reminded of God’s grace and mercy.
It’s for all of us who need to be reminded that God isn’t done with us yet—that there’s still a place for us next to Jesus and much work still to be done.
Amen.
